Is Standardizing Curriculum a Good Thing?

Last weekend, my nephew Ryan slept over our house.  He and my son, Ben are very good friends despite a two-year difference in age.  Ryan is a 6th grader, Ben a 4th.  On Sunday morning, they were talking about the day’s weather when Ben said,

“The weather should be okay, those are cirrus clouds outside.”

“Cirrus clouds?” Ryan replied.  “How do you know about those?… Oh yeah, you’re in the 4th grade.”

Ryan said it so matter-0f-factly that it didn’t occur to him that he was making a comment about the current status of the curriculum in the state of New Hampshire and made me think about whether or not the standardization of our curriculum has been a good thing.  While I have never been a full proponent of No Child Left Behind, I had always liked the fact that it help standardized curricula across our state.  It was troubling to me that due to the local control of school districts here in New Hampshire, that many times the level of curriculum exposure was solely dependent upon local school districts.   In my mind, what NCLB did, along with the state testing that NCLB mandated, was to standardized the content across the state, thus not allowing local districts to choose not to offer specific content. In other words, for the first time, the curriculum New Hampshire students were exposed to was independent of where they lived.

But, Ryan’s comments made me think?  He and Ben go to different schools in different districts.  Their teachers have probably never met, never mind share professional development opportunities, yet Ryan knew that as a fourth grade student, Ben was studying clouds.  Is that okay?  Is it okay that two students in two different school districts study the same things at the same times?  How do we allow teachers to customize or personalize programming for students if our curriculum is so standardized? How do we avoid turning our teachers into technicians as they mechanically maneuver through a prescribed curriculum?  How do we avoid teaching “clouds” in the fourth grade because they are on the state test?  I am happy that NCLB shed light on some of the inequities inherent in the institution of school as we have made strides in meeting the needs of our special education and economically disadvantaged students, but in doing so have we lost sight in the fact that school is a “people” business in that educators are in the business of creating tomorrow’s citizens?  Is a prescribed curriculum going to help us develop an informed and free-thinking citizenry?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Is Standardizing Curriculum a Good Thing?

  1. Do students in China know cirrus clouds by the end of 4th grade? I think your point is well made. Most of our standardized tests are measuring the lowest level of Bloom’s. What about creative and critical thinking skills? Are we testing for these? I think we can do both, but I do not think that we are ensuring that this is happening. We still have a lot of work to do! NCLB may have been a start, but it is time for Plan B.

  2. principalofchange says:

    I think standardized curriculum is a good thing. Think of all the time wasted in thinking of a scope and sequence for each school. Think about kids who transfer from one school to another. What a benefit to have curriculum decided upon. Of course, a standardized curriculum does not mean standardized teaching. Teachers should have the professional freedom to design their own best lessons to teach the curriculum for their grade – there can be lots of creativity. But at the end of the day, we do not have to worry about children missing out on important concepts because a school’s curriculum was mismatched or even just missing!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s